A Christmas market stall in Frankfurt stacked with sausages, cheeses and loaves of bread

Sausages, cheese and bread at the Christmas market in Frankfurt. Photo: Ed Brill

Earlier this month, at a gala in Lima, The 50 Best Restaurants named the best restaurant in the world. You may know the list by its old name, The World’s 50 Best. Since 2002, it has been fine dining’s version of the Oscars. More than a thousand chefs, critics and well-traveled diners vote in secret for places they have eaten in the past 18 months, and a spot near the top can bring reservations from around the world. This year the top spot went to Asador Etxebarri, a wood-fired grill in a Basque mountain village. I loved reading about it. I can also guarantee you I will never eat there.

Restaurant lists are a big deal all year. Canada’s 100 Best put Pearl Morissette, in Ontario wine country, at No. 1. Britain’s National Restaurant Awards chose Bouchon Racine, a London bistro, over The Ritz. The New York Times ranks the 100 best in New York, and the Michelin Guide keeps handing out stars. I read them the way some people read real estate listings in towns they will never move to.

The top tables book out months ahead, but I am not that kind of planner. If you are, the lists are a terrific guide. Earlier this year I made the case for booking the restaurants before the hotel.

But even a week out adds up to twenty or so meals, and the reservations cover only two or three. The rest happen when you are hungry and nowhere near the list. In Marrakesh, the meal we still talk about came from one of those afternoons, at a place four minutes away that none of us had heard of.

THE MENU

Those unplanned meals teach me the most about a place, and you can find them on purpose. The people who live there are proud of their favorite places, and most of them love to share. Some of the best things I have eaten cost less than the taxi to get there.

In Chicago, I have a habit. When I meet someone new, I ask where they live. Chicago calls itself a city of 77 neighborhoods, and every one has its regulars. Then I ask about their favorite restaurant nearby, the one they always go to, and what they think is the best dish. People lean in and talk me through the menu. Harvard researchers found that talking about ourselves lights up the same reward system in the brain as food and money. Their volunteers even gave up money for the chance to talk about themselves, so I like to think I am doing people a favor.

The second question does most of the work. Ask for the best restaurant, and you hear about the place they would take a visiting client. Ask for the one they always go to, and you hear about the place they keep paying for with their own money.

WHITE TABLECLOTHS

Friends who have been where I am going send lists full of can’t-lose places, which usually means the fanciest and most expensive. I understand why. A recommendation puts your own judgment on the line, and nobody ever got blamed for sending a friend to the place with the white tablecloths. So, I ask one more question. What if I cared less about the setting and wanted some of the best food in town?

Anthony Bourdain made a career in that territory. In 2016 he sat down with President Obama at Bún Chả Hương Liên in Hanoi, where the two of them perched on low plastic stools over grilled pork, noodles and cold Hanoi beer. “Total cost of bun cha dinner with the President: $6.00,” Bourdain posted afterward. “I picked up the check.”

I still read the online reviews, though I am never sure which ones to believe. In its latest transparency report, Tripadvisor said it removed 360,000 reviews tied to businesses rewarding their own staff for writing them. The waiter loved the risotto. He was also paid to. Ed Brill, our head of community and operations and a devoted Google Maps reviewer, swears by sorting reviews from lowest rated first, where the real scoop tends to be. Nearly every meal I remember came from someone who lived there.

THE POTATOES

Years ago, a shopkeeper in Paris sent me to a small restaurant well off the main streets. I could not tell you the name of the place now, or what was in the potatoes I was sent there for. I remember they were the best I have ever eaten. I couldn’t find that restaurant again, even if I tried.

By Paul M. Rand, Founder and Editor of Nomadic Spirit